ISPs Start Court Action Over Legality Of DEA

BT and TalkTalk have begun to frame their arguments in a court bid to overturn the Digital Economy Act

On by Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz 1

A legal challenge to the Digital Economy Act (DEA) 2010 has been launched by TalkTalk and BT in court today. The two ISPs are jointly arguing that the regulations are “seriously flawed” and “incompatible” with European law.

The Act requires ISPs to impose a  series of sanctions on illegal-file-sharers. The escalating procedure begins with a warning letter and culminates in a slowing down of the connection speed of persistent offenders or the temporary suspension of their connections.

Higher Costs Passed On To Consumers

Antony White, the QC acting for the ISPs, said these measures would “impact the privacy and free expression rights of customers”. If the challenge is successful, it will overturn what is seen by most ISPs as a hastily and imperfectly drafted law which was rushed through at the end of the Labour government’s term of office.

Despite these criticisms, the new coalition government’s business secretary Vince Cable will claim that the DEA complies with European law and contains sufficient safeguards to protect the rights of both the ISP and the consumer.

In his opening speech, White admitted that  the freedom of expression allowed by Internet access can lead to copyright infringement through illegal practices. However, he argued that the DEA requires ISPs to act when infringement is merely suspected and that actual law breaking would be difficult to prove. This would lead to higher costs for the ISPs which would be passed on to consumers – contrary to the aims of the Act.

“The Government brought forward these measures, and Parliament enacted them, anticipating they would result in benefits to copyright owners and the economy,” he said.

The hearing continues and could result in alterations or delays to the Act, which now may not be enforced until next year.


Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz
Author: Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz
Editor, ChannelBiz
Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz Eric Doyle, ChannelBiz
Techweekeurope for mobile devices
Android-App Google Currents App for iOS

Last comment

One reply to ISPs Start Court Action Over Legality Of DEA

  • On March 25, 2011 at 4:33 pm by CharliefromtheTrust

    I work with the UK film and TV industry and as an industry we are working hard to meet consumers’ changing needs by bringing innovative new services to market, on and offline. We’re also trying very hard not to “impact the privacy and free expression rights of customers” (Anthony White). Instead, we’re working to make these services as convenient and cost-effective as possible for consumers. We hope that by spotlighting the wide choice on offer, we can help persuade those people currently using unauthorised sources that there are a wealth of value-for-money, official alternatives.

Leave a Reply

  • Required fields are marked *,
    Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>