bbcuksurveytop

BBC Crowdsources UK 3G Coverage Map

The BBC is asking Android users to upload information which will map Britain’s 3G coverage

On by Peter Judge 8

The BBC has launched a project to map the UK’s 3G coverage, using data crowdsourced from users who have installed an app on their Android phone.

Measurement company Epitiro, who created the app, hope to collect data from around 10,000 people, and  publish the results as a map in August. Epitiro previously carried out a survey of mobile broadband for the telecom regulator Ofcom, which found that O2 had the fastest service. This time, the company is focusing on geographical coverage.

Free download charts coverage

The app is a free download, which sits in the background and detects when the phone has 3G signal, and when it has fallen back to 2G or has no signal at all. It uses virtually no data to operate and shares no personal data, Epitiro marketing manager Iain Wood assured eWEEK Europe.

“From this exercise, we are hoping that on a single map, people can look at where they live and see what coverage is available for each operator,” said Wood.

Epitiro and the BBC intend to publish the map before the end of August, in time for the holiday season, and hope more than 10,000 people will sign up to use it. “It’s a good time do this, with all the travelling that will be going on,” he said. “We’d like to cover every nook and cranny.”

The app only measures the presence or absence of signal, not its strength, and not the throughput achieved over it – but there could be evidence of places where the network is overloaded, if phones frequently fall back on 2G signal.

It is only available on Android phones because of the timelag and difficulty in getting apps into app stores for the iPhone and BlackBerry, but Wood hopes that future versions of the app might run on the iPhone.

Will it run up my bill?

Although the app itself  has limited usefulness for the user – it simply gives a tally of the percentage of time their phone was able to get a 2G or 3G signal (illustrated here), Wood hopes enough people will leave it running on their phone – and assured us very carefully that the app would not

“The app extracts information logged onto the phone at given times. There is no personal data involved,” he said. “It won’t add to the user’s phone bill – it is sending a quantity of data that is so minuscule it is not worth putting a number down for it.”

When the phone does not have GPS active, it will use coarser-grained location data based on the 3G network – but this will not be connected with the user’s identity.

The app also explicitly ignores cases where signal is boosted by femtocells – indoor base stations such as Vodofone’s Sure Signal – so it won’t give a measure of how well these devices are helping solve the UK’s mobile coverage issues.

Once the map is published, the BBC project will cease, but Wood hopes it will continue in some form.

When the map exists, could the information be fed into an app on the phone which would help users find coverage, eWEEK Europe asked Wood.  “We hadn’t thought of that,” he said. “We work on the measurement side.”

Peter Judge
Author: Peter Judge
Editor, TechWeekEurope
Peter Judge Peter Judge Peter Judge Peter Judge
Techweekeurope for mobile devices
Android-App Google Currents App for iOS

Last comment




8 replies to BBC Crowdsources UK 3G Coverage Map

  • On July 18, 2011 at 4:10 pm by android vs apple

    one could think it as a potential intrusion to privacy but overall its a good move.
    android vs apple

  • On July 18, 2011 at 5:04 pm by Peter Judge

    We’ve had a tweet from a comparable project – Open Signal Maps. “Peter, we’ve been creating an independent map of mobile phone coverage for over a year: ”
    http://opensignalmaps.com/

    The map seems to be based on what information people have uploaded already, so it shows gaps where there is actually coverage. The good side is you get the map right away, and don’t have to wait.

    Peter Judge
    Editor

  • On July 19, 2011 at 11:26 am by Tristan

    Warning, this application takes more permissions than necessary – it requests the permissions needed to modify and delete data on your SD card and the permissions needed to read and send your phone’s unique identity.

    That’s a lot more than needed to record the network state and send your location. It also uses unecessary battery by requiring permission to find you position to metres using GPS – where network positioning alone is more than enough to determine 3g coverage.

  • On July 19, 2011 at 12:10 pm by bruv vander schoot

    if i’m not mistaken, http://opencellid.org has been doing this for ages

  • On July 19, 2011 at 1:29 pm by AndyB

    and opensignalmaps requires even more permissions! prevent phone from sleeping, read phone identity, and full internet access as well as usb storage.

    I can understand the need to store information – it batches it up and then transmits the package instead of sending it all the time, but needs identity? Hmm.

    Still, it’d be nice for Epitiro to take the data from OSM and use that, OSM has been downloaded more than 250,000 times already and looks to be a nice little app that gives you a lot more information on your signal too.

  • On July 19, 2011 at 4:47 pm by Tristan

    @AndyB, android applications can store data in their own on-phone data stores. This app would not need to store bulk data so wouldn’t need access to my mp3s. It would even be easier not using the SD card so it’s quite remarkable that this app needs that.

    full internet access is required to be able to send data which this application does need.

  • On August 4, 2011 at 3:58 pm by 3g Coverage

    Alot of complaints that the app is quite resource heavy on your handset. Anyone confirm or deny this?

  • On August 4, 2011 at 4:38 pm by Peter Judge

    I don’t know. I deleted it from my HTC Desire, but then that has absolutely no memory left for anything.

    Peter

Leave a Reply

  • Required fields are marked *,
    Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>