Apple Stung By Mammoth Fine From Italian Watchdog

Apple has been handed a £750,000 fine for misleading customers in Italy over statutory product guarantees

On by Tom Jowitt 7

Apple has been slapped with an eye watering €900,000 (£750,000) fine by an Italian watchdog, which accused the iPad maker of misleading consumers over product guarantees.

The Italian Antitrust Authority said in a press release that the fines resulted from “Apple’s unfair business practices against consumers”.

Product Guarantees

The Antitrust Authority blamed Apple, Apple Sales International, and Apple Retail Italy for the implementation of what it deemed to be two “distinct practices of unfair trade”.

The first problem area concerned Apple’s point of sales (both the Apple Stores and its online retail presence) for failing to adequately inform consumers of their right to two years free technical support as provided by Italy’s Consumer Code. Apple apparently only offered its one-year standard warranty.

The second issue with Apple concerned its support plan, known as the Applecare Protection Plan. The Antitrust Authority felt that the company’s lack of information about the two-year guarantee, led many customers to pay extra for Apple’s support services.

The watchdog consequently decided to issue a stiff financial penalty of €900,000. It broke this down, saying €400,000 (£333,000) was due to Apple’s failure to recognise the length of the statutory guarantee as set out in Italy’s consumer code. The remaining €500,000 (£417,000) penalty was imposed because of the Applecare Protection Plan.

The watchdog also warned that Apple has to publish an extract from its ruling on its Website. It must also add details of Italy’s two-year guarantee to its Applecare plan within 90 days.

Legal Battles

Although it is likely to appeal, Apple has yet to respond to the issue of the fine, but will have no problem paying it. The company is in the enviable position of having at least $81 billion (£52bn) in cash sitting in the bank, thanks to its sales successes over the past decadewith its iPod, iPhone, and iPads.

Of late, Apple’s sales success has been attracting more and more probes by industry regulators and watchdogs. For example the EC has recently launched a probe to investigate whether Apple, along with five international publishers, have struck deals to fix the prices of e-books in Europe.

The company has also been waging a legal patent campaign against its competitors, most notably Samsung. So far, Apple has enjoyed considerable success against Samsung in many countries, although it has also had a number of setbacks.

Tom Jowitt
Author: Tom Jowitt
Freelance TechWeek Reporter
Tom Jowitt Tom Jowitt Tom Jowitt
Techweekeurope for mobile devices
Android-App Google Currents App for iOS

Last comment

7 replies to Apple Stung By Mammoth Fine From Italian Watchdog

  • On January 5, 2012 at 4:48 pm by Robbo

    when I read the headline ‘mammoth’ I figured hundreds of millions, or even millions. But no it’s not even a million. I guess to the author, it would be a mammoth fine, when they are more accustomed to parking fines etc….

    • On January 5, 2012 at 10:45 pm by Gabe Fabe

      Would largely agree with your comment, Robbo – the headline is pretty misleading. Apple’s legal costs in appealing the fine would probably not be much less than the fine itself (and would almost certainly be more by the amount of any reduction secured), but no doubt the appeal is being pursued as a matter of principle.

  • On January 8, 2012 at 7:07 am by Garth Banks

    It is not the amount of the fine that is the problem. It is the ignominy of being caught out in a sharp practice.

    Apple need to get bigger boots!

  • On January 26, 2012 at 6:56 pm by Paul

    Yep … Not even close to mammoth.

    That sort of money is an Apple team night bar bill.

  • On March 1, 2012 at 4:14 pm by Gerry

    I was supposed to be going for a job interview with techweekeurope next Tuesday. The salary was described as “substantial” – I suppose I’ll be living in a tent.

    • On March 1, 2012 at 6:04 pm by Peter Judge

      You are all hired for our humour section.

      The salary will be astronomical.

      (Seriously, thank you. We have toned down our adjectives since this story)

      Peter Judge

  • On March 4, 2012 at 6:07 pm by Peter Judge

    ..although we have just had an “infintely”
    (which is an adverb, anyway)


Leave a Reply

  • Required fields are marked *,
    Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>